Good quality wrought iron look. The surface finish is somewhat dull, roughed which is what I wanted. Not shiny. The non removable pin is purposely made a smidge loose I guess for the "colonial" effect. It's nice, but you do need to be a little more careful with the fitting the door and marking the hinge placement because there's a tiny shift. The included screws are ok. They were Philips head NOT the flat head screws shown in the photos. I didn't mind. Not really noticeable. Overall I'm happy. 4 stars. I did a DIY knee wall shelf and cabinet built-in. I combined the hinges with a Twisted Arch Pull from the same manufacturer.