We used a toaster oven on counter for years..The Hamilton Beach is super shiny retro looking .The toast ,bagels everything toast perfectly.

Looks just like the online pictures. It is an aluminum product, so it gets hot to touch while in use. Cools fairly quickly, though. Crumb catcher is easy to remove and replace. Works as described. I'm happy with the toaster.

Level Hides Function Buttons

Toasts OK. But one Issue is that the lever that is pressed to lower the bread obscures the control buttons for "bagel" or "cancel." That means that you have to lean down to read the controls.

Great for small and large pieces

When you want to toast big or small pieces, you can push them up, with the lever, without having to dig in and burn your fingertips...

[Rewarded Review] Looks matter!

Looks nice and that matters!

This is the replacement for the original toaster that was missing the rubber part for 2 of the 4 "feet" - this one was also missing the rubber. Very unhappy with this product and one of the worst toasters I have ever used.

[Rewarded Review] Terrible Toaster

Rinky-dink tin can of a toaster. I purchased this Hamilton Beach toaster to replace what I thought was the same HB toaster that has served this family daily for 20 years and boy was I disappointed. This feels cheap immediately out of the box. The buttons you need to use to hopefully get a decent piece of toast are artfully situated under the handle so that you can’t see them without bending down. You have to press a button if you are toasting one slice of bread or that bread will burn. It doesn’t accommodate the size of bread we have toasted in the alleged same model for years. Do yourself a favor and purchase a different toaster, this one is terrible.

Great toaster !

Great product ! Lots of choices in the extra features .

My grandmother had a Hamilton Beach toaster, which is, in part, what inspired me to buy this one. Now this is a fine toaster, don't get me wrong. But it does not fit my favorite bread, which is Dave's Killer Bread. I have to put Dave's Killer Bread in "sideways" in order to toast it. So maybe the length of the toaster slots could be a tad bit longer.

Nice features BUT bad smell & taste

Great features, I wanted to replace an old “classic” toaster almost exactly the same. When I first used it, it smoked and smelled horrible. I contacted the manufacturer and they said the smoke was normal and would clear up after 6-8 uses. The smell has continued for 50 uses and it makes the food taste very bad. I don’t know if it’s unhealthy but I can’t eat the toasted bread because of the taste. I am returning the toaster.

Cheap

Uneven toasting. Not level on countertop due to missing feet. Company says that’s how it’s made. Cheap toaster.

I'm going to have to rate this product five stars and I'll let you know why...not only is the toaster I purchased a top - notch product it's also the price ! And of course the free shipping you cant get any better then that right and let's not forget the great customer service you'll recieve. Thank Wayfair your just what I need

[Rewarded Review] Best Toaster Around!!

Just had the chance to use this toaster & I couldn't be more pleased!!Very easy to use, wether it be of one slice or two! Controls are easy to see and use, the 1st use was for bread being toasted for a sandwich. It toasted evenly on the center setting, see picture attached. I gave this toaster 5 Stars

+1 more

[Rewarded Review] Requires a learning curve.

This toaster was ready to go right out of the box but I should have read the instruction first. I've had many toasters in my 59 years of marriage and this is the first one that required flipping a bagel so the cut side faces out. I actually use the bagel setting for toasting buns so missing that important step resulted in overcooked outsides and just warm on the cut sides. I use the bagel setting daily and I still have to consciously insert the the bun correctly. This toaster also advertises "wide slots". I wish they were a little wider because I have to smash the top of the bun to get it in otherwise the top doesn't toast. On the positive side, it is an attractive appliance. It's easy to clean. I also like the Auto Boost to lift smaller pieces of bread. I also like the cancel button for the times I don't put the bagel and bun in correctly. I have noticed recently that when toasting bread the bottom 1/2 inch does not toast, but not always.

[Rewarded Review] Great toaster.

I desperately needed a new toster. My old one burned my toast even in the lowest setting. This one does a perfect job. I love that it has a setting for bagles and for only one slice of bread since i often only toast one. Gives me perfect toastes bread and bagles. The decine is nice and it doesnt take up too much space.

[Rewarded Review] Great toaster with so many options.

This is a great toaster. It has option of 1 slice or 2. Toast is cooked perfectly by setting the dial to how toasted you would like. My favorite feature is being able to get smaller items out by lifting it higher. Another unique function is the defrost setting. We stock up on bread and freeze so this helps when you forst to take a loaf out but want a sandwich.

[Rewarded Review] Perfectly toasted Bagels!

I received the Hamilton Beach Classic 2 Slice Toaster from Hamilton Beach to review it. Both my husband & I love bagels & this was the feature we were both the most excited about. It toasts the bagel perfectly & it doesn't get hard like it can with a regular toaster. As my husband says, it's toasty on the outside, yet soft on the inside. I also like that it will toast 1 slice of bread perfectly on both sides. We were a little confused at first about the inner coils turning off, but after trying 1 slice, we understand why, it keeps the toast from over browning. It also has a defrost button to use when you want to defrost frozen waffles.

Poor quality.

My order arrived promptly but the quality was extremely disappointing. Poor quality and temperature control. I am already ordering a replacement from a different brand. I would not order again.

Great appliance

Perfect house warming gift for a family member's new home. I have the same one and I have had it for years.. great quality and the red color adds character. Definitely a great buy.

love it

I can't complain about this toaster. I like it and the stainless steel look. Only thing I notice is that when it is finished it does pop up the toast, but you have to press the tab to completely pop up the toast to take it out. Other than that, toast perfect.