• Large Stainless Steel Non-Toxic Cookie Sheet
1 / 7

Large Stainless Steel Non-Toxic Cookie Sheet

$37.30
$24.78
34% off

Reviewers mentioned

See 21 reviews
Well made
Lacks durability
Large Stainless Steel Non-Toxic Cookie Sheet

Reviewers mentioned

See 21 reviews
Well made
Lacks durability

Large Stainless Steel Non-Toxic Cookie Sheet

$37.30
$24.78
34% off
Found at 2 stores ·Prices updated 41 minutes ago 
Store
Amazon
Lindy's Stainless Steel Heavy Baking Sheet, Non Toxic Baking Pan, Flat Oven Tray, Healthy Cookie Sheet
$24.78 
as of 02:03 11/27
eBay
$37.30 
Page 1 of 1

More like this product

View all

More Baking Sheets & Pans

Well made
89% positive
8 reviews
Lacks durability
62% negative
8 reviews

Reviews

it is great

it is great

Gregory L. · Review provided by lehmans.com
September 06, 2024

Excellent quality.

Excellent quality.

Harriette R. · Review provided by lehmans.com
February 12, 2024

Great find

Glad I managed to get one of these bad boys as stainless steel baking pans seem almost uncommon and unheard of in the US!

Braxton P. · Review provided by lehmans.com
October 28, 2023

Cookie sheet

This pan has a very nice finish, and is very sturdy. One problem, they warp, mine warped the first time I used it. It got better, than it got worse. now its only usable for certain foods. I highly don't recommend them.

Jon E. · Review provided by lehmans.com
October 17, 2023

Cookie Sheet Stainless Steel

It works great! I was tired of my other cookie sheets rusting out.

Diane C. · Review provided by lehmans.com
May 19, 2023

Cookie sheets

Love the quality of these! They should last my lifetime!

Audrey N. · Review provided by lehmans.com
April 12, 2023

Sheets

Mine warped the very first time I backed cookies in them.

Review provided by lehmans.com
February 14, 2023

Bought in 2019, doesn't warp

I bought two of these, plus the extra large one, back in (I think) 2019. The regular size are heavy, beautiful, have a great mirror finish, and have never warped. The double- size one is assists to be laid its finish, which started right away...I think they are replacing these for people but I can't find my receipt.)

Review provided by lehmans.com
November 03, 2022

There better than anything I

There better than anything I bought before

Mike D. · Review provided by lehmans.com
September 20, 2022

Good buy

Really like them but they are sensitive to slight temperature variations on the sheet (e.g. baking cold fish) and can temporarily warp. Once they cool down, the warp subsides.

Eric T. · Review provided by lehmans.com
August 17, 2022

For baking, not for roasting or broiling

Nice sheet for baking. Heads up: Keep oven at baking temperatures, not roasting or broiling -- if oven too hot, pan will warp.

Jennifer L. · Review provided by lehmans.com
August 13, 2022

I purchased these due to

I purchased these due to the positive reviews I read about them. All said that they were heavy and did not warp during baking, even at high temps. They are heavy and appear to be well-made, but mine warped the first time I used them and have never returned to their original shape.

Jenny S. · Review provided by lehmans.com
June 14, 2022

Disappointed

It's beautiful. And heavy. Which is why we were so surprised and disappointed that on our third or fourth use, it significantly warped while in the oven. Worse than any other baking sheet we've had. Then it did not flatten completely when it had cooled down. Also unlike any other baking sheet we've had. So, cancel the plans to order more.

Review provided by lehmans.com
March 10, 2022

OK

I bought two of these, only used one so far. They are heavy, however, the one I've used did warp and it wasn't put in a 450 degree oven either.

Review provided by lehmans.com
February 05, 2022

Warping

I agree in part with the other reviews. They don't stick, they are mirror finished, they are kinda heavy, they Brown evenly. These are only used for baking mainly cookies. The problem they warp every time we have used them. They return to normal shape after they cool down just kinda irritating. Sometimes cookies are lopsided.

Review provided by lehmans.com
December 18, 2021

The Best Cookie Sheets Ever

I've had my cookie sheets for several months now and I use them all the time for more than baking cookies and biscuits. These cookie sheets are really nice and top quality. They clean up well and I haven't had any issues with cleaning off anything. They are solid and heavy so they don't warp. I have found some foods cook and brown more evenly in these cookie sheets than any other cookie sheet or pan I've ever used in the past. That was a surprise to me. I've never had biscuits to bake and brown more evenly before I baked them on these cookie sheets. If you want a quality cookie sheet, these are the ones for you, they're great!

Review provided by lehmans.com
February 26, 2021

cookie sheets

We just received our cookie sheets and they are super nice. I was surprised how heavy they are!!!! My husband said you could use them for a mirror when you weren't baking with them!!! :) I baked with one yesterday and the food hardly stuck to the pan and the small cleanup was so easy. As always and true to Lehman's style....quality is top notch.

Review provided by lehmans.com
September 17, 2020

Hard to keep clean

Nice to finally find a stainless steel cookie sheet that does not have a non stick coating but it is really difficult to clean...?

Liza · Review provided by Walmart
May 05, 2020

Not solid stainless, plated junk, stay away.

All we used it for was to salt slices of eggplant before cooking. We have other stainless sheets that are nearly 40 years old that we have had no problem using this way, but they are smaller and we wanted to be able to do more at a time. This is now permanently stained and the surface appears to have been plated and the plating is pitted. Solid stainless would not do this.

Tubaguy · Review provided by Walmart
March 09, 2019

It was what it was advertised to be

The stainless steel baking sheet is very durable and attractive. It arrived in a very timely manner.

decoratingden7 · Review provided by eBay
December 05, 2017
Page 1 of 2

Customer pictures

Overview

We found this at two stores including eBayThis product sells from $24.78 up to $37.30. Users can save 33% by shopping at Amazon.

Prices are currently low for this product, typically ranging from $27 to $33, and the lowest price we've seen is $23.89.

This product is also marketed as the 

Lindy's Stainless Steel Heavy Baking Sheet, Non Toxic Baking Pan, Flat Oven Tray, Healthy Cookie Sheet at Amazon

.

Description

This large stainless steel cookie sheet is perfect for baking. Its non-toxic, durable design ensures long-lasting use, while the attractive mirror finish adds a touch of elegance to your kitchen. Dishwasher safe for easy cleaning.

Stores offered