One of them arrived damaged 3 star ?? given due to the fact

Great light. Good quality, very happy with this purchase

Good Looking Mid Century Lights, but Cheaply Manufactured

I love the look of these lights. They are as advertised in size, and material, but not finish. These are brushed and not satin! The brushing is so deep you can feel burrs. They are extremely bright when new, but do not have any lacquer to protect the finish from inevitable corrosion over time. My biggest disappointment with these lights is that the square mounting base is not square to the cylindrical shroud. This manufacturing flaw, which is consistent on all my lights both 5" and 14" models, sticks out like a sore thumb on my brick facade. I was left with the choice of mounting them with crooked cylinders or crooked bases. I chose the latter. I couldn't find a similar alternative in stainless steel so I chose to keep these, but am disappointed in the overall quality for the price.